What Happened
A recent report examined how often infections go undiagnosed or are caught too late in Fort Myers and the rest of Southwest Florida, and the malpractice questions that follow. The available material discusses the problem in general terms. It does not identify a specific patient, provider, or facility, and we are not aware of any court finding of fault connected to it. We will not speculate about details that have not been published.
The topic still matters to Florida families. In our experience, missed-infection cases tend to follow a similar pattern. A patient arrives at an emergency room, urgent care clinic, or follow-up appointment with warning signs such as fever, a racing heart, a red or draining surgical wound, severe pain, or sudden confusion. The symptoms are blamed on something minor, and the patient is sent home with reassurance. Over the next hours or days, the infection spreads. By the time it is properly identified, it may have progressed to sepsis, organ failure, amputation, permanent disability, or death.
Infections that are commonly involved include post-surgical wound infections, urinary tract infections that progress to urosepsis, pneumonia, spinal abscesses, meningitis, necrotizing soft-tissue infections, and hospital-acquired infections such as MRSA. Not every bad outcome is malpractice. When a provider overlooks the red flags that a careful provider would have caught, however, the law may allow the injured person or the family to hold that provider accountable.
Who May Be Liable
Responsibility in a missed-infection case often reaches beyond one person. Depending on the facts, any of the following could be liable:
- Emergency room physicians, physician assistants, and nurse practitioners who may have failed to order basic tests, misread results, or discharged a patient who showed signs of a serious infection.
- Nurses and nursing staff who may have failed to monitor vital signs, recognize deterioration, or alert a physician.
- Hospitals and health systems, both for the conduct of their employees and for their own decisions about staffing, sepsis screening protocols, and infection control.
- Surgeons and surgical centers, when a post-operative infection was allegedly not recognized or treated in time.
- Urgent care and walk-in clinics, which see a large number of patients with early infection symptoms.
- Nursing homes and assisted living facilities, where residents with pressure wounds or urinary catheters are especially vulnerable.
- Laboratories and radiology providers, if test results were allegedly misreported or not communicated.
If the provider is a public hospital or a government-run facility, Florida’s sovereign immunity law may apply. That law sets special notice rules and limits on recovery.
Legal Theories That May Apply
- Medical negligence: Under Florida law, a provider may be liable for failing to meet the prevailing professional standard of care, meaning the level of care a reasonably careful provider in the same field would give.
- Failure to diagnose or delayed diagnosis: A claim may arise when a provider allegedly missed signs of infection that should have prompted testing or treatment, and the delay made the outcome worse.
- Failure to treat: Even when an infection is identified, a provider may be liable for allegedly giving the wrong antibiotics, starting them too late, or failing to involve a specialist.
- Vicarious liability and apparent agency: A hospital may be responsible for the negligence of its employees. In some cases it may also be responsible for doctors who appeared to work for the hospital even though they were technically independent contractors.
- Institutional negligence: A facility could be liable for its own failures, such as poor infection-control practices, understaffing, or careless credentialing of providers.
- Wrongful death: If an alleged missed infection led to a death, Florida’s Wrongful Death Act may allow the estate and certain survivors to recover damages.
Damages Victims May Recover
When an infection is missed, the harm can be catastrophic and permanent. Depending on the facts, injured patients may be able to seek:
- Medical expenses, past and future, including ICU care, surgeries, amputations, prosthetics, and rehabilitation
- Lost wages and lost earning capacity when a person can no longer work as before
- Pain and suffering, mental anguish, disfigurement, and loss of enjoyment of life
- Loss of consortium for a spouse whose relationship has been affected
- Wrongful death damages, including lost support and services, loss of companionship and guidance, and the survivors’ mental pain and suffering. The estate may also recover medical and funeral expenses.
- Punitive damages in rare cases. Florida law generally requires a showing of intentional misconduct or gross negligence, and the court must allow the claim before it can proceed.
Families should also know about a Florida rule that limits who may recover non-economic damages in a medical malpractice death case. In certain situations, adult children of an unmarried parent, and parents of an adult child, may be barred from recovering for their grief and loss. An attorney can explain whether that rule may affect your family.
Evidence That Strengthens a Case
Missed-infection claims are often won or lost on timing: what the providers knew, when they knew it, and what they did about it. Useful evidence can include:
- Complete medical records, including triage notes, nursing charts, physician orders, and discharge paperwork
- Vital signs and lab values over time, such as temperature, heart rate, blood pressure, white blood cell counts, lactate levels, and culture results
- Electronic health record audit trails, which can show when results were viewed and whether entries were changed later
- Hospital policies, including sepsis screening and infection-control protocols
- Imaging studies and radiology reports
- Photographs of wounds and a written timeline of symptoms kept by the patient or family
- Statements from family members who were present and heard what providers said
- Independent medical expert review. Florida requires a qualified expert to support a malpractice claim before a lawsuit can be filed.
What to Do Next
If you believe an infection was missed, these steps can help protect your rights:
- Request your medical records from every provider involved. Florida law generally gives patients the right to copies of their records.
- Write down a timeline of when symptoms began, who you saw, and what you were told.
- Keep everything, including discharge instructions, prescriptions, bills, and appointment cards.
- Photograph visible injuries, such as wounds or surgical sites.
- Be cautious with insurers and hospital risk managers. Avoid recorded statements until you have spoken with a lawyer.
- Stay off social media about your condition or your care.
- Act promptly. Florida’s malpractice deadlines are strict. The state also requires a pre-suit investigation and notice process that can take months to complete.
If you or a loved one suffered serious harm after an infection may have been overlooked, you deserve clear answers about what went wrong. Managing Attorney Michael E. Dean and the team at Dean Law Firm LLC help Florida families pursue accountability for catastrophic injuries and wrongful death. Call (352) 820-6323 for a free Florida case evaluation – no fees unless we win.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue if the ER sent me home and it turned out I had a serious infection?
You may have a claim if the emergency room providers allegedly missed warning signs that a reasonably careful provider would have recognized, and the delay made your condition worse. Not every missed diagnosis is malpractice, so the key questions are what your symptoms and test results showed at the time. A qualified medical expert’s review is usually needed to answer that.
How long do I have to file a medical malpractice claim in Florida?
Florida generally allows two years from the date you knew, or reasonably should have known, about the injury and the possibility that malpractice caused it. There is also an outer limit that usually bars claims filed more than four years after the incident, with limited exceptions for situations such as concealment or injuries to young children. Because Florida also requires a pre-suit investigation, it is wise to speak with a lawyer well before any deadline.
What if I caught the infection while I was in the hospital?
A hospital-acquired infection is not automatically malpractice, but a facility may be liable if the infection resulted from a failure to follow proper sterilization, hand hygiene, or infection-control practices. A claim may also exist if staff allegedly failed to recognize and treat the infection promptly once it developed.
Is sepsis automatically considered medical malpractice?
No. Sepsis can sometimes develop even with excellent care. A malpractice claim may exist, however, if providers allegedly ignored signs such as fever, a rapid heart rate, low blood pressure, or abnormal lab results, or delayed antibiotics that a careful provider would have started sooner.
Can I file a wrongful death claim if my parent died from an untreated infection in Florida?
A wrongful death claim is typically brought by the personal representative of the estate on behalf of the surviving family members. Florida has a rule that may prevent adult children of an unmarried parent from recovering non-economic damages, such as grief, in medical malpractice death cases. Other damages, such as medical and funeral expenses, may still be recoverable, so it is worth having an attorney review your situation.
Does Florida cap how much I can recover in a malpractice case?
The Florida Supreme Court has struck down the state’s caps on non-economic damages in medical malpractice cases. Claims against government-run hospitals or public providers may still be subject to sovereign immunity limits. The value of any case depends on the severity of the injury and the strength of the evidence.
What if the doctor who missed my infection didn’t work for the hospital?
Many emergency room doctors in Florida work for outside staffing groups rather than the hospital itself. The doctor and the doctor’s group may still be liable. In some situations, the hospital could also be responsible if it appeared to patients that the doctor was acting on the hospital’s behalf.
Original reporting: lawyer-monthly.com.
